The Model

Henry S. Rzepa and Christopher Leach

This was performed at the PM3 level with H2N=CH2 (+) as a hydride acceptor from a H-C-OH system. Two transition states are currently identified, with energies of 101.2 and 97.8 kcal/mol, a difference of 3.4 kcal/mol. The details are shown below
Low energy
97.8
High Energy
101.2
Click on the diagram to activate RasMol. If you don't know how to do this, its practice for my talk!!

The Theory

It looks uncannily like the reverse of the epoxidation system we published a year or so back. There, the C-CF3 bond was in the plane of a ¼ system so as not to deactivate the nucleophilic p orbitals towards the electrophile. Here, we have in effect a nucleophilic hydride, and a C-F bond effectively orthogonal to an incipient ¼ system system activating the p orbitals towards nucleophilic attack. Almost the exact oppposite of before! The favoured ts has a "W", although the central CH2 is bent out of plane by virtue of the conjugation of the hydroxyl group.

Next Steps

We want to repeat at the ab initio level, construct contour diagrams, try CF3 groups, and replace the imino group with a proper NADH system. But I think we have the start of a theory here.